Itโ€™s the time of the year again when we put on our best suit jacket, sit in front of the TV and try to save our favourite football club. The new Football Manager is here, and our objective is simple: donโ€™t let your partner see you performing an imaginary press conference in front of absolutely nobody!

My relationship with the Football Manager series goes as far back as 2013. It actually predates most of my relationships, so I hold this series close to my heart. But like every relationship, it has its ups and downs. It started with FM13 in my parentsโ€™ apartment, continued with me while I packed all my belongings and moved to a different country, and is still with me now that Iโ€™ve started my own little family. The last few years, however, have been quite rough. Iโ€™ve since switched to the PlayStation 5 version, the series took a year off, and last yearโ€™s launch didnโ€™t go according to fansโ€™ expectations. Weโ€™re here to answer one question: is Football Manager back as we all love it?

Letโ€™s meet my coaching staff: a two-month-old son and a very needy Cockapoo. An ideal setup, really. They always agree with my tactical decisions, as long as I keep their addictions going, one with baby formula and the other with salmon bites. They are both, however, starting to catch on to my little lie: one more game and we are going to bed.

Creating your manager

We start the game with manager creation. From a visual standpoint, not much has changed, and the options are still quite limited. Here you choose your gender, physical appearance and clothing. This yearโ€™s addition is the option for your manager to use a powered wheelchair. I think this is a great step towards greater inclusivity and representation.

Manager creation screen in Football Manager 27 showing a manager using a powered wheelchair.
Your manager can now take to the touchline in a powered wheelchair.

We then choose our Playing Career background, which ranges from an International Legend to a Lower League Veteran. Besides that, we can also choose from a number of Non-Playing Roles, such as pundit or coach. These won’t have much impact on your actual gameplay if you’re starting off employed with your team of choice. At least, not on the Console version. When starting unemployed, the story is a little different. The higher your reputation, the better offers you could potentially receive.

We can have up to ten active nations per save, including women’s leagues. You can customise this however you like, keeping in mind that the more leagues you include, the slower the game processing can become. I’ve tested ten nations on PlayStation 5 and didn’t find the game to be noticeably slower. Leagues you haven’t selected are still present in the game world, but stats aren’t generated for them, and you can’t manage a club in a nation you didn’t include when starting your save.

You can choose from 161 playable leagues across men’s and women’s football, although not all of them are fully licensed. One of the most notable examples is Serie A, where around half of the teams have generic names and badges, although the rest of the information is correct. Unlike FM26, international management is available right from the start, meaning you can take on a club and national team at the same time if you’re a real workaholic.

Shuffle Draft

New addition this year besides the usual experience is Shuffle Draft, a head-to-head game mode where you can compete against friends or AI-controlled teams in either a knockout tournament or a league. With a minimum of four players, everyone takes turns drafting from sets of 20 players. Each round is timed, so the draft moves along at a pretty quick pace.

Itโ€™s a fun way to put your player knowledge and tactical thinking to the test, but most importantly, to settle the big question: whoโ€™s the best manager in your friend group?

A much-needed menu makeover

The first big difference hits you right after you pick a team and load into your management screen. Menus now use the whole screen, they’re much bigger and don’t seem overloaded with unnecessary information.

Last year’s game, especially at launch, made me question whether I needed an appointment with an eye doctor. Menus are now much more intuitive and easier to navigate. You don’t want to play a game where you need to Google “where do I find my youth team setup in FM26?” Thankfully, this doesn’t happen anymore.

Using a controller works much better now, but it still feels like this game needs to be played with a mouse. We started this review using a controller, but eventually opted for a controller and mouse setup.

Football Manager 27 Console management screen showing the redesigned full-screen menus.
A cleaner, more organised dugout. The new menus make finding your way around much easier.

Tactical Effectiveness: missing in action

One big thing that’s missing compared to the PC version is the new Tactical Effectiveness feature. To be honest, I didn’t even realise it was missing until I started looking for it. At first, I thought it was the same situation as last year: another “you need to Google where to find it” type of thing.

Once I searched online, I discovered that it hadn’t made it into the Console version. The frustrating part is how I found out. With Tactical Effectiveness being one of the major advertised additions to FM27, I expected it to be part of the Console experience too. Instead, its absence was confirmed through an official forum Q&A rather than being clearly communicated in the Console announcement. You can probably imagine my reaction.

Once I got over the Tactical Effectiveness situation, I found that there were still some additions worth mentioning. More statistics are now being tracked, giving you more information to analyse and helping you understand whether your tactics are actually working, or not.

Training and match preparation

Training has also received some changes. Even though I prefer to delegate most of it to my assistant, it now comes in three categories: In Possession, Out of Possession and Set Pieces.

You now receive a weekly message in your inbox where you can select three unique training sessions to prepare for an upcoming match. You can either delegate this to your assistant or pick the sessions yourself each week, depending on what you want to work on against a particular opponent.

It’s a welcome addition, giving you another way to prepare your team and make adjustments depending on the challenge ahead.

Football Manager 27 Console squad screen showing the team roster and player information.
Your squad, their strengths and all the important details, neatly laid out in one place.

Match engine and Tactical Tweaks

The match engine still runs on the same underlying engine, but the experience feels much smoother. I’ve noticed a big difference in player movement, and sometimes I stopped and said to myself, “This would never have happened in previous games.”

I mean this in the best way possible. Players now seem to have more football IQ and can make better decisions on the pitch.

One new feature that I ended up using quite a lot during matches is Tactical Tweaks. These give you preset tactical instructions that allow you to make significant changes with the click of a button, rather than going into your tactics and changing everything yourself. These include options such as playing with more patience, playing out from the back, swapping wingers or throwing the kitchen sink at your opponent.

I found myself using the last one quite a lot when chasing a game towards the end. It doesn’t always work out, but at least you can say you tried everything!

A more challenging experience

I found the game a bit more challenging this year. My first save record with Liverpool says it all: one goal scored in four matches, while world-class players consistently underperformed.

It’s not just about tactics anymore. Of course, they still matter, but it doesn’t feel like before, where one tactic could seemingly fix everything. I like this change. You now have to pay more attention to matches and statistics, identify where things are going wrong and work out what you need to improve to get the most out of your players.

After my miserable scoring record, a few tactical tweaks and some attacking training sessions, both in and out of possession, got us back on track.

The little things matter

Manual cup draws are back. I know that, on a scale of things, this is a tiny upgrade compared to its predecessor, but the small things matter.

The Football Manager series is all about giving us players the experience of being a football manager. Little details that enhance that experience make a lot of difference. You pick your tactic, you pick your team, you go to a press conference and you hear the Champions League anthem right before kick-off. All of these things give you the full experience of what this game is about.

It’s not necessarily about the feature itself, but the feeling it creates. You’re not just managing a collection of players on a screen. You’re building a club, preparing for matches and experiencing those little moments that make football special.

Football Manager 27 match in which a centre-back has taken over in goal after the goalkeeper was injured.
No substitutes left, goalkeeper injured. Sometimes you just have to stick a centre-back between the sticks and hope for the best.

The final whistle

So, is Football Manager back? I believe so!

FM27 feels like a proper step in the right direction. After the disappointment surrounding last year’s release, it’s refreshing to see that developers have listened to fans and addressed many of the issues that made FM26 such a frustrating experience. The improved menus alone make a massive difference to the everyday experience, while the smoother match engine and more challenging gameplay give you plenty of reasons to keep coming back.

Is it perfect? Absolutely not. The missing Tactical Effectiveness system is a frustrating omission, especially when it’s one of the major additions to the PC version. The Console edition is still very much the “lite” version of Football Manager, and there is clearly room for improvement.

But here’s the thing: I’ve enjoyed playing FM27. I’ve enjoyed analysing my team’s performances, changing tactics, trying to figure out why my world-class attackers suddenly forgot how to score and convincing myself that one more match won’t hurt. More importantly, I’ve found myself wanting to come back for another game.

Football Manager has been part of my life since 2013. It has followed me through different countries, different stages of my life and now into fatherhood. FM27 reminds me why I kept coming back in the first place. It might not have everything I want, but the foundations are finally in a good place again.

And if you’ll excuse me, I’ve got a Champions League final to prepare for. The coaching staff have already gone to bed.

IS IT WORTH LOSING SLEEP FOR?

๐Ÿ›๏ธ๐Ÿ›๏ธ๐Ÿ›๏ธ๐Ÿ›๏ธ๐Ÿ›๏ธ

4/5

Worth losing sleep for.

How the beds work โ†—

Enjoyed this? Keep in touch.

Get an email when we publish something new. No noise, just new posts.

Leave a Reply